THE Department of Energy’s National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) is looking to accomplish even more within its budget constraints, as it pursues a smaller, safer, more secure, and less expensive nuclear weapons complex. Meeting that goal means relying on advanced scientific tools and procedures to assure a high level of confidence in the performance of aging weapons in the stockpile. The longer confidence in the performance of an aging weapon system can be assured, the longer the nation can keep the system as part of a credible nuclear deterrent without having to refurbish the weapons or produce replacements.
In response to NNSA’s needs, Livermore physicists, engineers, and computer scientists have developed a new computed tomography (CT, also known as computerized axial tomography or CAT) x-ray system to image nuclear weapon components removed temporarily from the stockpile for inspection. The Confined Large Optical Scintillator Screen and Imaging System (CoLOSSIS) consists of a scintillator (a material that emits light when struck by ionizing radiation); a pyramid-shaped central mirror; four turning mirrors; and four high-resolution, low-intensity visible-light charge-coupled-device (CCD) cameras. The system’s software assembles the collected digital radiographs into a large three-dimensional (3D) image that scientists can “walk through” to discover any problems or anomalies.
CoLOSSIS was recently installed at NNSA’s Pantex Plant near Amarillo, Texas. The overall CT system includes a 9-megaelectronvolt (MeV) linear accelerator and a tungsten target (built by Varian, Inc.) that produce the x-ray beam, three tungsten collimators that shape the x-ray beam and prevent unwanted scatter, and a positioning table that securely holds the test object and rotates it in precise increments for the CoLOSSIS detector.
A typical CoLOSSIS inspection comprises about 1,500 separate radiographic images taken of an object from all sides. The radiographs are then assembled, using Livermore-developed tomographic image algorithms, to provide a 3D reconstructed image with greater resolution than previously achieved using a 9-MeV x-ray system. Nearly all elements of the inspection system—x-ray source, collimators, positioning table, detector, and tomographic algorithms—contribute to its high-resolution capability.
Pantex is the nation’s only nuclear weapons assembly and disassembly facility. To maintain the reliability of the nation’s nuclear weapons stockpile, weapons are randomly selected and transported to Pantex for testing and evaluation. X-ray radiography is used to probe inside the nuclear pit of a weapon in a nondestructive manner; that is, the weapon does not have to be dismantled. Plutonium pits are one of the most important components routinely inspected. Tests on these pits can reveal structural variations arising from so-called birth defects (manufacturing flaws) or from aging. Potential variations include cracks, voids, gaps, and density variations.
Livermore chemist Pat Allen, deputy program manager of the Laboratory’s enhanced surveillance effort, says, “Without x-ray diagnostic tests at Pantex, we would have to resort to destructive evaluation of these very expensive weapon components. With the right diagnostic tools, we can conserve valuable resources by eliminating some destructive procedures and disassembly operations.”
“Livermore’s role in helping to develop CoLOSSIS reflects the strong nondestructive evaluation capability at the Laboratory,” says Allen. A core competency at Livermore, nondestructive evaluation is a means of examining and identifying flaws and defects in materials without damaging them. Laboratory engineers routinely use x-ray, ultrasonic, acoustic, infrared, microwave, visible-imaging, and other noninvasive techniques to examine defects, measure properties, and accurately determine part thicknesses of materials for a variety of research programs. CoLOSSIS is currently undergoing final qualification at Pantex. Future inspections at Pantex will generate important data for scientists and engineers at Lawrence Livermore and Los Alamos national laboratories, the two centers of nuclear weapon design and engineering.
Quest for Higher Resolution
Livermore physicist Jim Trebes says that traditional black-and-white film can exceed the resolution of digital radiography in a single image. However, film has certain drawbacks. For example, many people with film expertise have retired, the film industry is in deep decline, and environmental controls on film-processing chemicals are increasing. The biggest drawback to film, though, is that it does not lend itself easily to processing 3D views. Trebes says, “If we know a feature exists in a certain location, we can easily record it with film. However, if we are performing a survey to look for problems, 2D film radiography is not sufficient because a subtle region can be obscured by another material or component.”
Recognizing film’s limitations, NNSA managers urged the development of a CT system to be installed in an existing x-ray inspection bay at Pantex with a goal of obtaining greater resolution and contrast to detect even the slightest manufacturing flaws and changes in materials from aging. With 3D imaging, scientists could examine any discrepancies from many different angles. “We want to see features as small as 2 or 3 mils (thousandths of an inch), equivalent to 50 to 75 micrometers, in very-high-density components,” says Allen. “The best resolution for 9-megelectronvolt x-ray CT has until recently been 6 to 8 mils, or 150 to 200 micrometers.”
CT scanners are commonly used in the medical field to take multiple radiographic views of a patient and then compute them into 3D images. More than 30,000 CT scanners worldwide are in use, mostly in hospitals. A medical CT scan is performed by rotating the x-ray source and detector around the patient. In contrast, CoLOSSIS does just the reverse: The x-ray beam and detector remain stationary, while the object is rotated 0.25 degrees for each succeeding picture.
Trebes notes that Livermore researchers regularly perform CT x-ray scans to examine tiny fusion targets for the National Ignition Facility, the world’s most energetic laser. They also certify critical components for the National Aeronautic and Space Administration and for U.S. manufacturing companies.
Applying digital CT to weapons inspection poses a particular set of challenges. The procedure requires a source of x rays (typically an electron accelerator), a stage to position and move the object, a detector (scintillator), cameras to capture the image, and software to process the images. The source-object-detector configuration must be both thermally and vibrationally stable to avoid blurring the image. The room must be shielded to reduce backscatter into the detector and to protect the electronics and any personnel located in adjacent rooms. The x rays must penetrate thick, dense materials with much higher energy than a medical x ray (9 MeV instead of less than 100 kiloelectronvolts). Also, the inspection must achieve a much higher resolution of 75 to 100 micrometers compared to the millimeter scale sufficient for medical applications.
Prototype in 2000
The initial results provided the impetus to build a more refined system with improved resolution. NNSA asked a team of Livermore scientists to work with Pantex managers in designing a CT system and to oversee its manufacture, assembly, and qualification. The resulting CoLOSSIS inspection system was built by OPTICS 1, Inc., with Livermore researchers and Pantex engineers providing technical assistance in specifying system requirements, design, setup, and operator training. Livermore computer scientist Dan Schneberk led the development of tomographic software.
In developing the optical and electronic requirements for CoLOSSIS, Livermore researchers originally specified one camera with an 8,000- by 8,000-pixel field of view. However, Trebes and Schneberk discovered that such a camera was not available commercially and would cost about $25 million to design and build. As a result, OPTICS 1 designed an instrument using four 4,096- by 4,096-pixel digital cameras and a novel optical configuration for collecting and transferring images.
The movable CT system weighs almost 16 tons, excluding the x-ray source. Much of this weight comes from the lead shielding used to protect optical lenses, CCD camera chips, and sensitive electronics from the powerful x rays. The shielding includes a core of three lead “exhaust” tubes with 3.5- to 4.0-centimeter-thick walls and an outer array of large lead-lined removable shields supported by a steel exoskeleton. The removable shields permit personnel access to internal CoLOSSIS components.
CoLOSSIS at Work
The collimators are supported on a steel support frame attached to a linear rail transport system, allowing for easy movement forward and backward. Each collimator features four adjustable jaws made of tungsten alloy, an x-ray absorbing material. Once aligned, the collimators and jaws are locked into position because errors in alignment or the movement of collimator components could cause excessive x-ray scatter and possibly damage the CCD cameras.
The shaped x-ray beam inscribes a cube measuring about 24 centimeters per side. A heavy, stable platform with a precision-leveling system aligns the test object and holds it in position for CT data collection. The x rays penetrating the test object cast a shadow on a glass scintillator that converts the x radiation to green light (a wavelength of about 540 nanometers).
The light emitted from the scintillator is then bounced off a pyramid-shaped mirror. The light bounces in four different directions onto four identical 20-centimeter-diameter turning mirrors.
The turning mirrors then reflect the light onto four 16-megapixel CCD cameras. The cameras, similar in design to those used for terrestrial astronomy, are cooled to minus 100o C. OPTICS 1 designed the custom lenses, while the cameras were built by Spectral Instruments, Inc., with help from the University of Arizona. Each lens comprises eight elements arranged into six groups. The lenses image light onto each camera’s 16-megapixel (4,096 by 4,096 pixels) CCD chip, equal to an active area of about 6 centimeters per side. The CCD chip converts light to voltage and provides 65,000 levels of gray.
The turning mirrors can be adjusted so that the light falls upon the four CCD cameras in perfect registration. By using two mirrors in each optical chain, the CCD cameras are shielded from the direct x-ray beam. “The CCDs have been pulled out of the main beam path with a neat optical trick,” says Allen. Schneberk compares the mirror geometry to a periscope that permits observation without being in harm’s way.
Each digital image from the four CCD cameras is immediately downloaded to the adjoining control room, where four computer servers, one for each camera, are located. Control electronics for the cameras and cryogenic refrigeration systems are housed at the rear of the system, shielded from the direct x-ray beam. During operation, personnel remotely adjust the mirrors, lenses, and cameras from the control room.
The pyramid-beam-splitting architecture allows for the four images from the cameras to be seamlessly stitched together using Schneberk’s software. Each quadrant of the scintillator has a small overlap (20 to 50 pixels, about 1 percent) with the adjacent quadrant to assist the stitching procedure. The software stitches the four separate images into one by eliminating the overlap and creating an 8,000- by 8,000-pixel radiograph.
Each of the four images contains 32 megabytes of information, for a total of 128 megabytes per stitched view. A typical scan comprises 1,500 digital radiographs, each requiring up to 90 seconds, and each separated from the next by a 0.24-degree rotational change. In all, the data set is about 192 gigabytes. Each image takes 30 to 90 seconds, with 1,500 views requiring about 72 hours, spread over several days.
The complete data set is transferred to Lawrence Livermore or Los Alamos, where the individual images are reconstructed into an approximately 1-terabyte 3D file using Livermore-developed software. “Joining all 1,500 2D images into an incredibly detailed 3D image takes several days of computer time,” says Stone.
To view the 3D image, computer scientists combine four 3,200- by 2,300-pixel monitors to form essentially one large monitor. A weapons scientist can “walk through” the test object for an overall look in any direction or zoom in on a tiny subsection and proceed micrometer by micrometer deep into a part.
15-MeV System on the Horizon
For the next several years, however, the 9-MeV CoLOSSIS system will provide a vital opportunity for NNSA to inspect stockpiled weapons more efficiently and thoroughly than current technology permits as well as provide scientists with a technical basis for future CT designs. Says Allen, “We’re seeing more than ever before.” For weapons scientists, seeing more means greater confidence in aging nuclear weapons—and in America’s national security.
Key Words: Combined Large Optical Scintillator Screen and Imaging System (CoLOSSIS), computed tomography (CT), nondestructive evaluation, Pantex Plant, radiography, stockpile stewardship, x ray.
For further information contact Pat Allen (925) 423-8955 (email@example.com).
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
Privacy & Legal Notice | UCRL-TR-52000-09-7/8 | August 11, 2009